It’s only existential – a briefing prepared by Aberystwyth UCU
This is to provide to members and to students a sense of the scale, causes and possible actions needed to address what is an obvious crisis in higher education in Wales.
Welsh higher education and research are at risk. The consequences will extend far beyond universities including; reduced economic activity and growth, fewer skilled graduates retained in Wales, reducing the capacity to train future NHS and public-sector workforces, and weaker innovation, research and business support in Wales.
Whilst often presented as a purely financial crisis the longer-term issue is the destruction of institutional capacity to operate as educational, research and economic loci for communities and the nation. This is therefore a systemic crisis, not just one of individual institutions facing challenges.
Governments cannot operate on the basis universities will find ways to manage their way out of a crisis created by a combination of inadequate funding and a policy framework that is not fit for purpose. Nor can it assume that damage already inflicted on the sector and due to be amplified in coming months can simply be reversed at a later date. Urgent government intervention and investment is needed to prevent irreversible damage. The decisions taken now will determine the future of higher education in Wales for a generation.
The Challenges
Unsustainable Funding
The current model of funding student education is unfair to students and staff and insufficient to sustain Welsh higher education. It results in a structural funding gap of £80 – £100 million a year. While direct government funding has largely remained flat since 2012 the costs of delivering this public service have continued to rise.
Financial instability
Seven of eight Welsh HE institutions reported underlying operating deficits in 2024/25. All have adopted measures to cut costs. Forecasts have proven overly optimistic with operating deficits deteriorating year on year. Risk and resilience is not equally distributed, with for example 85% of sector cash balances concentrated in three institutions [Medr 2026] and the others increasingly exposed to fiscal shocks and changes in regulatory environment.
Welsh universities continue to generate substantial economic[1] and social value for Wales, yet most of them now operate in deficit.
No Welsh university will fail because the need for higher education has disappeared. The crisis we can see around us is the product of policy choices made over many years that have steadily reduced the resources available for teaching and research while expecting universities to deliver ever greater economic, social and civic benefits.
Wales IS different
Wales has a distinct higher education and employment landscape. The nation has historically been and continues to be a net exporter of its skilled human capital to other parts of the UK. Participation in education at age 18 is significantly below the UK average at 29% according to UCAS data, and the percentage of our young people Not in Education, Employment or Training (‘NEET’) is the highest in the UK nations. Three of Wales’s eight campus universities are based in predominantly rural and linguistic heartland communities and all universities have close relationships with partner schools.
Just the numbers
The sector employs around 22,000 staff, with pay accounting for approximately 55% of expenditure. Medr forecasts a 15% reduction in FTE staff between 2024 and 2028. This will not be evenly distributed.
Direct income to Welsh HE institutions was £1.90 billion in 2024/25, 55% from fees. In 2024/25 Medr estimate Welsh universities reported an operating deficit of £81 million.[2] Universities Wales now put that figure at £130 million.
Analysis by London Economic for Universities Wales estimated Welsh universities generated nearly £11 billion total economic impact for the UK economy in 2021/22. Productivity spillovers from Welsh university research and knowledge exchange activities are estimated to contribute £1.98 billion.[3]
Research capacity and capability
Welsh research capacity is being steadily eroded. Financial pressures on universities lead to cuts in research infrastructure and staffing, which undermines their ability to compete for research funding. Lost research expertise and investment in estate becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Anchor Institutions
Universities are more than businesses. They are anchors of regional economies, culture and civic life. They are a public good forced to operate within a market system.
Universities maintain specialist laboratories, libraries, historic buildings, collections and other assets which have long-term maintenance costs, poorly recognised within current funding models. Like universities themselves, once they are gone they are very hard to regenerate.
A Vicious Cycle
Driven by UK and Welsh government inaction and regulatory pressure, every Welsh university has announced cuts to staffing, restructuring of operations, has planned for or made changes to course provision, and scaled back expenditure on estate and maintenance. Such cuts have been the ‘solution’ for nearly a decade yet the crisis in Welsh higher education has not actually been resolved. By their very nature they undermine the capacity universities need to recover.
The actions
- Government, regulators and HE institutions should outline a clear ambition for higher education as a skills and research axis for building Welsh social, economic and environmental cohesion and enhancement. This should articulate the role universities are expected to play to meet economic development, widening participation and social mobility goals and the contribution of university research and training to meet future high skills needs of Wales.
- Welsh Government must address the structural underfunding of higher education in Wales and establish a sustainable settlement for the distinct public missions of universities, namely; educating students, conducting research, and delivering economic, social and cultural benefits to communities across Wales.
- Welsh Government must challenge the UK Government/Treasury directly over the structural inequity created by pegging Welsh student funding and living-cost support to the funding regime and decisions of the UK Government for England. As Pedussel and Dickinson describe the current model “is bankrupting three nations’ universities.”, whilst simulataneously loading unsustainable levels of debt onto students. [4]
- Higher education institutions are established in their host communities explicitly to maximise social impact, public benefit through teaching and research, and provide the foundations for future innovation and economic opportunities. Welsh Government must recognise universities not only as anchor institutions but as essential public infrastructure within its economic, industrial, skills and regional development strategies.
- Wales needs to understand the extent and longer-term consequence of measures taken to address short-term financial positions in recent years. Medr must be tasked with publishing a comprehensive assessment of the consequences of institutional cost-cutting measures over the previous five years, including staffing reductions, course closures, research capacity, student-support services, capital spend on maintenance of estate.
- Wales receives a disproportionately small share of UKRI funding (just 2% of UKRI investment). Welsh universities are further disadvantaged by reduced levels of foundational research funding, provided by Welsh Government through QR funding, compared to the other nations. Welsh Government and UK Government must address this if Wales is to compete fairly and effectively for UK and international research funding.
1] London Economics (2024) The economic impact of Welsh universities’ teaching, research, and innovation, [Available at: https://uniswales.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2024-10/LE%20-%20Universities%20Wales%20-%20Impact%20of%20Welsh%20universities%20-%20Final%20report.pdf ]
[2] Medr (2026) Finances of higher education institutions, August 2024 to July 2025, [Available at: https://www.medr.cymru/en/News/sta-medr-09-2026-finances-of-higher-education-institutions-august-2024-to-july-2025/ ]
[3] London Economics (2024) The economic impact of Welsh universities’ teaching, research, and innovation, [Available at: https://uniswales.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2024-10/LE%20-%20Universities%20Wales%20-%20Impact%20of%20Welsh%20universities%20-%20Final%20report.pdf ]
[4] Pedussel, J., and Dickinson, J. (2026) The Treasury is bankrupting three nations’ universities, WonkHE [Available at: https://wonkhe.com/blogs/the-treasury-is-bankrupting-three-nations-universities ]
